More Minorities Discharged Under DADT
SANTA BARBARA, CA – The military continued to fire mission-critical
specialists for being gay in fiscal year 2009, according to new data released today. The data show that
gay discharges included 8 linguists, 20 infantrymen, 16 medical aides, 7 combat engineers, 6 missile
artillery operating crew members, and one member of the Special Forces, among others.
According to Aaron Belkin, “These data show, yet again, that ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ undermines
national security. Why are we firing linguists and infantrymen in the middle of two wars?” Belkin is
Director of the Palm Center, the research institute at the University of California that released the data
today. A sample of the new data is below and the complete dataset is posted at
The data confirm a long-term trend, and a 2005 Government Accountability Report found that the
military fired 757 mission-critical specialists, including 322 linguists, in the first decade of “don’t ask,
don’t tell.” JD Smith, co-Director of OutServe, said that today’s news shows how “don’t ask, don’t
tell” jeopardizes the safety of the troops. “These discharges put our lives at risk,” Smith said. “As
leadership continues to fire gay service members in critical career fields, it is the troops on the ground
who will pay with their personal safety.” OutServe is the first-ever organization made up exclusively
of currently-serving gay and lesbian troops. It now includes more than 500 members.
The new data were collected by the Defense Manpower Data Center and made available by the House
Armed Services Committee. They were submitted to the Committee in compliance with current law
which requires each of the services to disclose on an annual basis the number of service members who
have left the service, why they left and what jobs they performed.
“The next few weeks will determine the future of ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’” stated Christopher Neff, Palm
Center Deputy Director. “After 13,500 discharges, hundreds of millions of dollars and 17 years, it all
University of California • Santa Barbara, CA 93106-9429 • (805) 893-5664 • www.palmcenter.ucsb.edu
comes down to the Senate.” The Senate is expected to address the policy shortly after it reconvenes
from the August recess on September 13.
The Palm Center also noted that the data showed disproportionate discharges on the basis of race and
gender. In the Navy, two officers were discharged in FY 2009 and both were Asian. In the Army, of
the five Officers discharged, two were African American, one was Asian and two were white.
Although women comprise only 14% of the Army, lesbians received 48% of the Army’s “don’t ask,
don’t tell” discharges in FYI 2009. In the Marines, women comprise just 6% of the force, but received
23% of discharges under the policy. The numbers represent a dramatic shift from last year, when
women received 36% of Army discharges and 18% of Marine Corps discharges. In the Air Force,
women comprise 20% of the service but received 51% of “don’t ask, don’t tell” discharges in FY 2009.
Women comprise 14% of the Navy but received 27% of the discharges last year.
The Palm Center is a think tank at the University of California, Santa Barbara. Since 1998, the Center has been a
leader in commissioning and disseminating research in the areas of gender, sexuality, and the military.