Louisiana Weekly, News Report, Kevin Weston
“New Orleans Five Years After The Storm: A New Disaster Amid Recovery,” the third survey in a series that Kaiser has conducted in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, also finds the scope and immediacy of the Gulf oil spill weighing heavily on New Orleans residents’ minds. Asked which disaster would cause more damage, more people pointed to the oil spill than picked Katrina and the levee breaks that followed the hurricane.
In the last several years several charter school advocacy groups have released studies that indicate that New Orleans residents believe the school system is improving. But the Kaiser Foundation study found that 64 percent of Black New Orleans residents were “very worried” that their children won’t be able to get a good education, compared to only 18 percent of whites.
The study also found that 61 percent of African-American residents-report living in low-income households, 66 percent say that New Orleans has not recovered, and 51 percent say New Orleans is a worse place to live than before the storm compared to 35 percent of whites.
Overall, the survey reveals a markedly changed city, with a population nearly a third smaller than it was at the time of the 2000 Census, still struggling to recover from a storm and levee breaks that killed 1,464 people and displaced more than a million others while flooding entire neighborhoods and swamping local businesses and medical facilities. While residents see significant progress in restoring tourism, many report that New Orleans lags in overcoming an intractable crime problem and that the pace of the recovery has been far slower for the city’s Black residents, who are the majority.
‘Residents report a lot of progress in the recovery effort, but just as the city appeared to be turning a corner it got hit by a different kind of hurricane — the oil spill,’ said Kaiser President and CEO Drew Altman. ‘It is striking that while jobs is the number one issue across America, crime swamps all other issues in New Orleans,’ he added.
The survey series gauges people’s experiences, living conditions and attitudes towards the rebuilding effort in New Orleans in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. (Previous surveys were conducted in 2008 and 2006.) It finds that 70 percent of residents say recovery and rebuilding are going in the right direction, up from 56 percent in 2008 and 58 percent in 2006. Yet nearly six in 10 believe the city has not ‘mostly recovered’ from Katrina. A third (32%) of residents who lived through the storm report that their lives still are ‘very’ or ‘somewhat’ disrupted, compared to 41 percent two years ago and 46 percent in 2006. Nearly a quarter of residents (24%) are planning or considering a move away from greater New Orleans, up from 12 percent in 2006. And seven in 10 believe most Americans have ‘forgotten’ the continuing challenges facing the region.
The Gulf Oil Spill: A New Disaster for New Orleans
The Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, the largest offshore spill in U.S. history, amounts to a new, man-made disaster for greater New Orleans. Nearly half of the city’s residents (49%) believe the fallout from the oil spill represents a more damaging threat to New Orleans than Hurricane Katrina did, while 40 percent thought Katrina caused more damage. Large majorities say the spill will affect the New Orleans economy (64%) and the local environment (70%) a ‘great deal.’
BP, the company that operated the doomed oil rig, has come in for scathing public criticism even in a region heavily dependent on the oil and gas industry for jobs, with 84 percent of New Orleans residents reporting a negative view of the company’s response to the crisis.
Residents See Progress In Restoring Tourism, Repairing Damaged Levees And Rebuilding Devastated Areas
Most residents of Orleans Parish see real progress on a majority of recovery issues, the survey finds. Their greatest praise is for strengthening New Orleans as a tourist and convention site, with nearly nine in 10 residents (87%) saying they see ‘some’ or ‘a lot’ of progress in that area. Two-thirds (65%) see progress in repairing the damaged levees, pumps and floodwalls. And roughly six in 10 say they see progress making public transportation more available (62%), rebuilding destroyed neighborhoods (59%) and strengthening the public school system (57%).
In particular, this year marks the first time since Katrina that a majority of residents say they see progress in rebuilding devastated areas, with a solid majority of 59 percent saying so now, compared to 44 percent in 2008 and 33 percent in 2006.
‘The people of New Orleans believe that the Katrina recovery, while far from complete, is on the right track in a number of areas,’ said Mollyann Brodie, Senior Vice President and Director of Public Opinion and Survey Research at the Foundation.
In other areas, residents are more divided. They are split in half on whether the city has shown any improvement in making affordable housing more available, attracting businesses and jobs, and making it easier for people to access medical services.
Crime Is By Far The Biggest Concern
By far, residents reserve their lowest ratings for crime, an area in which nearly two in three people (64%) say the city has made little or no progress. Just over half of city residents (54%) are at least somewhat worried about becoming the victim of violent crime. Asked in an open-ended question to name the ‘single-biggest problem facing New Orleans today,’ crime rises above all other issues, with more than three times as many residents (41%) putting it at the top of the list as picked the oil spill (12%), the second most-cited problem. Farther down the list were jobs (8%), education/schools (7%), affordable housing (6%), the economy (3%), hurricane protection (2%) and health care (1%).
In contrast, when residents of Detroit, another major city facing tremendous challenges, were asked in a recent Kaiser/Washington Post/Harvard University survey about the single biggest problem in their area, 57 percent named economy-related issues while only 18 percent cited crime and safety. Nationally, the top concern is the economy, cited by 28 percent of people in a June USA Today/Gallup poll, followed by unemployment (21%). Crime was well down the list nationally at one percent.
Crime was a major problem in New Orleans even before Hurricane Katrina. The New Orleans Police Department, long viewed as troubled, suffers from a lack of public trust and is currently being assessed by the Justice Department at the request of the city’s new mayor. The survey finds that less than half of Orleans Parish residents say they can trust the police to do what is right for them and their community ‘almost always’ (13%) or ‘most of the time’ (31%). Trust in the police differs starkly by race: A majority of whites (59%) says you can trust the police to do what is right ‘almost always’ (18%) or ‘most of the time’ (41%), while a majority of Blacks (64%) says you can trust the police only ‘only some of the time’ (45%) or ‘almost never’ (19%).
Blacks And Whites Continue To Live Differing Realities in NOLA, but More People Cite Income Than Race As The City’s Dividing Line
As was true before Katrina hit, African-American and white residents in New Orleans live substantially different economic realities, an experience not uncommon in America’s large cities. But the storm, and especially the ensuing flooding, disproportionately affected Black neighborhoods, translating into a steeper climb to recovery in the very areas of the city that faced higher economic and other challenges even before the hurricane.
The survey finds that Black New Orleans residents are more than twice as likely as whites to say that their own lives have not yet recovered from Katrina (42% vs. 16%). And 61 percent of African-American residents report living in low-income households with earnings under 200 percent of the poverty level (roughly $44,000 for a family of four), compared to 24 percent of whites. Similar racial differences exist in the share who say New Orleans has not recovered (66% of Blacks vs. 49% of whites); who say it is a bad time to be raising children in the city (51% vs. 35%); who say that NOLA is a worse place to live now than before the storm (42% vs. 28%); and who say they are ‘very worried’ that healthcare services might not be available if they need them (59% vs. 21%).
Yet the survey also finds signs that race relations in the region may be improving. For the first time since 2006, more parish residents say that race relations are getting better (23%) than say they are getting worse (15%). The share of African-American residents who see racial bias in the rebuilding effort has dropped to 30 percent, down from 55 percent in 2006.
Moreover, while nearly six in 10 residents still see New Orleans as divided by race and income, the proportion that see a unified city has risen from 24 percent in 2008 to 37 percent today. Even among those who see divisions, more see the city as divided mainly by income (33%) than see it as divided mainly by race (17%). Black New Orleans residents express this view more than whites, with 37 percent of Black residents saying New Orleans is mainly divided between rich and poor, while 27 percent of whites say so. (In contrast, 24 percent of whites point to race as the main divide, while 13 percent of Blacks do.)
A Health System Slowly On The Mend
The picture is mixed on the recovery of the healthcare system, with 49 percent of residents reporting that they see ‘a lot’ or ‘some’ improvement in the availability of medical services and facilities and an equal share saying there has been little or no progress in this area.
For the first time, a majority (55%) say their healthcare needs are being met ‘very well,’ up from 42 percent in 2008 and 36 percent in 2006. And an increasing proportion say they have received preventive care in the past six months — 59 percent, up from 47 percent in 2008. Still, one in five adults report being uninsured, and about a quarter of residents say that they have no usual place of care other than the emergency room.
The expansion of health coverage under the new health reform law is expected to shrink those uninsured numbers. The survey finds more support for the law in New Orleans than there is in the nation as a whole. The city’s residents favor the law by a margin of 57 percent to 30 percent, compared to a narrower margin nationally of 50 percent to 35 percent in Kaiser’s July Health Tracking Poll.
‘New Orleans Five Years After the Storm: A New Disaster Amid Recovery’ is the third in a series of surveys designed and analyzed by a research team from across the Kaiser Family Foundation led by Senior Vice President and Director for Public Opinion and Survey Research Mollyann Brodie and Associate Director for Public Opinion and Survey Research Claudia Deane.
Interviews for the current survey were completed May 26 — June 27, 2010, in English and Spanish via landline telephone and cell-phone among 1,528 randomly selected adults ages 18 and older residing in Orleans Parish.