Today's Date: March 1, 2024
SharpHeels to bring Fortune 100 leaders together during International Women's Day Summit   •   Willdan Selected for $46 Million Energy Savings Contract for Nation’s 5th Largest School District   •   2024 Consumer Behavior Report: Influence + Impact   •   CA Lt. Governor Honors Nation’s First Transgender Facility Vote Center   •   Union: Nova Scotia’s “modest” surplus should be used to address the cost of living   •   Minister Boissonnault announces funding to make post-secondary education more affordable for Indigenous youth   •   Voices for Non-Opioid Choices Coalition Applauds Introduction of Alternatives to PAIN Act in Senate   •   Chevron announces its first solar-to-hydrogen production project in California’s Central Valley   •   Introducing the ASIANRESOURCEHUB.ORG, a Data-Rich Exploration of Anti-Asian Hatred   •   Russell Innovation Center for Entrepreneurs (RICE) Secures $2 Million Investment from Truist to Continue Accelerating Black Entr   •   Market Street Memory Care Residence Palm Coast Honored with Prestigious Reputation 800 Award   •   Ampace Has Sparkled at the World Smart Energy Week in Japan, Spearheading a New Era in Green Energy   •   Hyundai Pays Tribute to the African American Community in Commemoration of Black History Month   •   CIBC ranked #1 in Canada for gender equality by Equileap for fourth consecutive year   •   Maine Celtics and Sun Life U.S. team up to bring Fit to Win program to Boys and Girls Club of Southern Maine   •   Workers and leaders from universities across Ontario to join striking York academic workers Friday   •   Energy Vault Announces China State Grid Interconnection of First EVx 100 MWh Gravity Energy Storage System, Groundbreaking of Th   •   GoMacro® Announces New Annual Give Back Partnerships Promoting Autism Advocacy   •   Aptar Named One of Barron’s 100 Most Sustainable U.S. Companies for the Sixth Consecutive Year   •   Federal Home Loan Bank of Dallas Commits $79.4 Million to Affordable Housing Program – $50 Million More Than 2023 Commitme
Bookmark and Share

NAACP President Challenges Rand Paul To Debate

by Benjamin Jealous

Last night on the Rachel Maddow Show, I challenged Kentucky political hopeful Rand Paul to a debate. Mr. Paul has made headlines for his opposition to certain aspects of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the landmark legislation that outlawed racial segregation in voter registration, schools, workplaces and other public accommodations like hotels and restaurants.

 

The Civil Rights Act heralded the modern era of our nation's history; one in which race-based discrimination, on paper at least, was relegated to our history texts. It is a law that also doubles as a calling to our better nature.

In one sense I have got to hand it to Rand Paul. It takes some serious guts to publicly challenge such a cherished pillar of the modern American identity. Unfortunately, in the political arena, guts need to be tempered with brains as well.

Mr. Paul says that he supports all efforts to fight government-sponsored discrimination. He has no quibble with the end of segregation in public schools, for example, or in public-sector hiring. His only dispute is with desegregation of the private sector — the local merchants and lunch-counter operators whose speech rights were apparently encroached on by an overzealous federal government. In Mr. Paul's worldview, the free hand of the marketplace would have eventually forced most of those businesses to serve black folk anyway, because it was in their economic interest to do so.

The problem is that it never quite worked that way. Even after Jim Crow laws were overturned, those business establishments that bucked the system and served an integrated clientele faced threats, coercion and violence from a ruling class — a group made up not merely of local thugs, but of fellow business owners and, far too often, the local police force itself.

This was the point of federal intervention in the first place. The states and municipalities on the front lines of the desegregation movements were themselves the most likely to be institutionally corrupted by the cancer of racism. A relatively more objective outside party — the federal government — would have to serve as a mediating force.

Of course the story went far beyond potential corruption. Let's assume that we are dealing with a completely race-neutral local political environment. Society still relies on government enforcement — a police force — to enforce its laws. In Mr. Paul's world, a white gas station owner would be completely within his rights to deny service to a black family traveling on a holiday road trip. But say the family took a stand — refusing to leave the station until they were allowed to fill their tank or buy a snack. Do we honestly accept that it is the role of the municipal police force to step in and protect the owner's "right" to discriminate based on race? That they should arrest and charge the offending family for trespass?

The fact is that the world is far more complex than Mr. Paul's college dorm theoretical exercises would suggest.

Does Rand Paul defend, for example, the right of banks to not extend mortgages to people of color? Even in communities without other banks to compete? Should the government never be allowed regulate private business. Even for health and safety reasons? Honestly, I don't think Mr. Paul has thought these positions through very deeply. That is is why I have challenged him to study up on the subject and discuss them publically.

By winning his party's nomination to represent them in the Senate, Rand Paul has signed on to the big leagues. I say congratulations — let's talk about the issues. It is time for a debate.

Benjamin Todd Jealous is part of Change.org'sChangemaker network, a network comprised of leading voices for social change.

 



Back to top
| Back to home page
Video

White House Live Stream
LIVE VIDEO EVERY SATURDAY
alsharpton Rev. Al Sharpton
9 to 11 am EST
jjackson Rev. Jesse Jackson
10 to noon CST


Video

LIVE BROADCASTS
Sounds Make the News ®
WAOK-Urban
Atlanta - WAOK-Urban
KPFA-Progressive
Berkley / San Francisco - KPFA-Progressive
WVON-Urban
Chicago - WVON-Urban
KJLH - Urban
Los Angeles - KJLH - Urban
WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
New York - WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
WADO-Spanish
New York - WADO-Spanish
WBAI - Progressive
New York - WBAI - Progressive
WOL-Urban
Washington - WOL-Urban

Listen to United Natiosns News