September 29, 2020         
Regal Ware Finalizes Acquisition of ESPRO   •   Jordin Sparks, Ashley Everett and Melissa Butler Raise a Glass to the Beauty of Black Women in Barefoot Wine's 'We Stan for Her'   •   HHS Secretary Praises Department of Motor Vehicles for Their ‘Pivotal Role’ in Another Record-Setting Year in Organ   •   United Sewing Automation Announces Production of USA-Sourced and Manufactured Children and Youth Sized PPE Face Masks   •   VTech® KidiZoom® Creator Cam, LeapFrog® 100 Animals Book™ and Blue's Clues & You!™ Really Smart Hand   •   Relevent Sports Group Launches 'Women's International Champions Cup Best XI' to Honor Those Advancing Women's Soccer   •   Xena Workwear Breaks into Marketplace with Innovative Line of Fashionable Safety Shoes & Blazers   •   Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Announces New Family-Friendly Online Environment to Support Caregivers in At-Home Learning   •   PMI to Address Equality & Transformation During Upcoming International Events   •   Michigan Independent Living Communities Pine Ridges of Garfield, Plumbrook, Shelby Treated with MicroShield 360 Antimicrobial Co   •   Freddy's Celebrates National Frozen Custard Day Promotion With $20,000 Donation To Kids In Need Foundation   •   The Manufacturing Institute Recognizes U. S. Steel Chief Financial Officer Christine Breves With STEP Ahead Award   •   LUCA Science Announces Joint Research with the University of Oxford, Nuffield Department of Women's & Reproductive Health, o   •   Michiganders Invited to Fight Race-Based Hair Discrimination With New MiCROWN Campaign From Campbell Ewald — Natural Hair   •   Black Voices for Black Justice Fund Launches to Support Activists Working to Create an Anti-Racist America   •   HCPLive® and the American Lung Association Unveil Exclusive Interview with Anthony S. Fauci, M.D.   •   USAFacts Launches Major Campaign to Empower Americans to Use Data to Inform Their Decisions Ahead of 2020 Election   •   Maine Media Workshops + College Announces Jon Henry as Recipient of 2020 Arnold Newman Prize, One of the Nation's Largest in the   •   Women’s Health Care Costs in Retirement Projected to be $200,000 More than Men’s   •   Latino support for Trump grows… to John McCain's levels
Bookmark and Share

Parenthood Not Defined By Gender

 ST. LOUIS  — The continuing debate over same-sex marriage has put the issue of gender at the forefront of conversations about whom the law recognizes as a child’s parents.

“The shift in family law’s treatment of gender has been transformative,” says Susan Appleton, JD, family law expert and the Lemma Barkeloo and Phoebe Couzins Professor of Law at Washington University in St. Louis.

Family law has gone from a regime that “systematically and explicitly classified by gender and subordinated women, especially married women, to a body of rules that, with few exceptions, insists that gender must be ignored, at least formally,” Appleton says.

Some legal scholars and activists, however, resist what Appleton calls “family law’s equality project.” They argue, she says, for an “integrated model of parenthood,” which would bring together biological and other functions and aspects of parentage.

Appleton challenges the constitutional validity of the integrated approach because “most proponents of the model conclude that children need exactly one mother and one father — a gendered combination missing or disrupted when a child has two legal parents who are both women or both men, when a child has only one legal parent, or in the occasional case in which courts have recognized three legal parents for a given child.”

Appleton supports legal recognition of a diverse range of parent-child relationships, without regard to sex or gender. She argues that this diversity approach follows directly from family law’s equality project, with its rejection of traditional gender roles and sex-based classifications.

“Family law today seeks to change the way things are, not reinforce existing gender scripts and inequities,” Appleton says.

“Proponents of the integrated model fail to provide a persuasive reason why gender should matter legally even if men and women perform parental functions differently,” she says.

The legal debate about gender and parentage has increasingly relied on empirical data from the social sciences claiming to show how children fare in different familial arrangements.

“Although the most recent studies provide support for the diversity approach and evidence from the social sciences might be valuable on a range of issues, looking to these data to resolve whether gender should matter in the law of parentage is misguided, regardless who momentarily holds the upper hand.” Appleton says.

“Studies looking at sexuality, gender performance and family characteristics are fraught with value judgments, and findings about overall wellbeing are often met with counter-evidence, among other problems.

“Such studies also often reflect the marginalization of nontraditional families under the prevailing legal regime, including the exclusion of same-sex couples from marriage in most states,” she says.

Appleton says that parentage rules are important because of the authority and responsibility that family law invests in those individuals deemed parents and the relative lack of legal status and protection accorded to non-parents.

She discusses her support for the diversity approach to the law of parentage and the problems in constructing a legal regime based on empirical findings in “Gender and Parentage: Family Law’s Equality Project in Our Empirical Age,” a chapter in the forthcoming book, What is Parenthood?


STORY TAGS: GENERAL , BLACKS , AFRICAN AMERICAN , LATINO , HISPANIC , MINORITIES , CIVIL RIGHTS , DISCRIMINATION , RACISM , DIVERSITY , RACIAL EQUALITY , BIAS , EQUALITY



Back to top
| Back to home page
Video

White House Live Stream
LIVE VIDEO EVERY SATURDAY
alsharpton Rev. Al Sharpton
9 to 11 am EST
jjackson Rev. Jesse Jackson
10 to noon CST


Video

LIVE BROADCASTS
Sounds Make the News ®
WAOK-Urban
Atlanta - WAOK-Urban
KPFA-Progressive
Berkley / San Francisco - KPFA-Progressive
WVON-Urban
Chicago - WVON-Urban
KJLH - Urban
Los Angeles - KJLH - Urban
WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
New York - WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
WADO-Spanish
New York - WADO-Spanish
WBAI - Progressive
New York - WBAI - Progressive
WOL-Urban
Washington - WOL-Urban

Listen to United Natiosns News