July 2, 2020         
The ODP Corporation Releases 2020 Corporate Sustainability Report   •   Food Safety When Eating Outdoors   •   Coty Names Sue Y. Nabi Chief Executive Officer   •   Trend Micro and Girls in Tech Partner to Help Close the Gender Gap in the Technology Industry   •   Bay Area Kids Laptop Company Takes On Systemic Inequalities   •   e.l.f. Beauty Announces Agreement with Marathon Partners   •   Most Americans Not Very Comfortable Returning to Restaurants, Retail Stores and Hotels for Next Three Months, Survey Shows   •   Creative Healing Opens New Rittenhouse Square Location, Bringing Support Services to Center City Philadelphia Teens   •   Joelle Eckstein Turns Her Pain Into Purpose. The Eckstein Fund Remains a Beacon of Hope in Loving Memory of a Husband and Belove   •   New Report Shows Child Care Centers Slowly Recovering after COVID-19 Closures   •   Citizens for a Pro-Business Delaware Slams Delaware Department of Correction and Governor Carney for Politicizing Mask Donations   •   francesca's® Partners With Poq to Develop Mobile Application   •   'Alyssa's Law' Signed By Florida Governor Requiring Panic Buttons In All Schools   •   TopTec, the Manufacturer of the Air Queen FDA 510k Approved Surgical Respirator N95 Equivalent, Has Launched a New Specially Siz   •   Santander US Announces $5.2 million in Giving and Initiatives Supporting Social Equity   •   ¡HOLA! TV is added to Spectrum, strengthens presence in the US   •   Nintendo Download: Invert Your Aim, Invert Your World   •   Proposition 21! – California Rent Control Ballot Measure Now Heads to Voters in November as Campaign Rolls Out 200+ Endors   •   P&G to Webcast Discussion of Fourth Quarter 2019/20 Earnings Results on July 30   •   Rental Affordability Act Endorsed by Top Latino Leaders, Taps NorCal Campaign Regional Chair
Bookmark and Share

Rights Activists Defend The 14th Amendment

New America Media, News Report, Deirdre Ruscitt

WASHINGTON - The debate over illegal immigration has moved to a new territory: the U.S. Constitution. 

Under the 14th Amendment, U.S. citizenship is granted automatically to nearly everyone born in the United States, including the children of undocumented immigrants. (There are a few exceptions, such as the children of foreign diplomats.) This Constitutionally protected right, called “birthright citizenship,” could be the next frontier for anti-immigration politicians and activists, who seek to deny citizenship to the U.S.-children of undocumented immigrants. 

The latest attack on the 14th Amendment came from Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., who argued in an interview on Fox News that birth tourism—parents coming to the United States for the sole purpose of giving birth to a child and getting that child U.S. citizenship—“cheapens American citizenship.” Graham said he supports an overhaul of the laws that govern who gets U.S. citizenship, the basis of which is the 14th Amendment.

The non-partisan Immigration Policy Center rejects Graham’s views on birthright citizenship. “We are talking about changing the U.S. Constitution, the 14th Amendment, the cornerstone of civil rights,” said senior policy analyst Michele Waslin. “Repealing birthright citizenship would affect every American and every child born in the U.S.” 

Changing the rules of citizenship would not only change the rules for the children of immigrants, but also for the children of citizens, notes Margaret Stock, an attorney who works with the Immigration Policy Center. If the 14th Amendment were revoked, a U.S. birth certificate would no longer be sufficient proof of citizenship, so every child would have to go through a lengthy bureaucratic process to show that they meet all the requirements of citizenship. Such a change could cost billions of dollars.

“Before we change the rules, we need to do a cost-benefit analysis here,” said Stock. “There’s absolutely no attention being paid to the practicality.” 

In order to change a Constitutional amendment, a second amendment must be passed to override the first one, which can be an incredibly difficult process. Two-thirds of Congress and three-quarters of the state legislatures would have to approve the amendment, a level of consensus that observers say would be almost impossible to reach on an issue as contentious as immigration. 

“It politically can’t be done,” said Bill Hing, a professor at the San Francisco School of Law. “It can’t be a serious proposal.” 

Immigration experts also note that birth tourism, the process that Lindsey stated as his motivation, is in fact a rare occurrence. 

“There’s maybe a very small group of people who are coming to the U.S. solely to give birth to a child,” said Stock. Changing the Constitution to punish this small group of people, Stock continued, is an overreaction. “You don’t hit a fly with a sledgehammer,” she said.

Birth tourism has stayed limited, Waslin said, because a child’s immigration status has no immediate effect on the status of the parents. Children who have U.S. citizenship have to wait until they turn 21 to sponsor their parents for a Green Card. “It doesn’t make much sense to have a child here for citizenship reasons,” she said.

For immigrant rights advocates, the larger argument against revoking birth citizenship is that it is a threat to civil rights. They note that the civil rights movement of the last century and a half has been derived from the 14th Amendment, and to repeal it would destroy much of our American identity.

“Never before have we the people amended the Constitution to make it less egalitarian,” said Elizabeth Wydra, chief counsel of the Constitutional Accountability Center. “The provision of citizenship by right of birth was constitutionalized beyond politics and prejudices.”



Back to top
| Back to home page
Video

White House Live Stream
LIVE VIDEO EVERY SATURDAY
alsharpton Rev. Al Sharpton
9 to 11 am EST
jjackson Rev. Jesse Jackson
10 to noon CST


Video

LIVE BROADCASTS
Sounds Make the News ®
WAOK-Urban
Atlanta - WAOK-Urban
KPFA-Progressive
Berkley / San Francisco - KPFA-Progressive
WVON-Urban
Chicago - WVON-Urban
KJLH - Urban
Los Angeles - KJLH - Urban
WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
New York - WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
WADO-Spanish
New York - WADO-Spanish
WBAI - Progressive
New York - WBAI - Progressive
WOL-Urban
Washington - WOL-Urban

Listen to United Natiosns News