Today's Date: January 24, 2021
SF's Walk for Life West Coast Goes On!   •   Luxury Card Announces New Partnership With AMOREPACIFIC in the US   •   Helping Hand for Relief and Development Paves A Path of Success Through Education Support   •   Krylon® Brand Blends Natural Elements and Virtual Escapes with 2021 Spray Paint Color Palette   •   100 Black Men of Atlanta, Inc. Honors the Legacy of Member and Baseball Hall of Famer Henry "Hank" Aaron   •   Ric Edelman Shares the Investment Strategy You Need Now That the Election is Over   •   Disney Announces Digital Summit Inspired by Minnie Mouse in Celebration of National Polka Dot Day   •   RBB Bancorp Declares Quarterly Cash Dividend of $0.12 Per Share   •   1 Habit Press Releases the Ultimate Play Book for Life - 1 Habit to Thrive in a Post-Covid World   •   Status of Women Ministers Endorse Declaration for a Canada Free of Gender-Based Violence   •   Athleta Adds Extended Sizing to 350 Styles in Its 200 Stores and Online   •   Curtsy Raises $11M To Scale Clothing Resell App for Gen Z   •   100 Black Men of Atlanta, Inc. Honors the Legacy of Member and Baseball Hall of Famer Henry "Hank" Aaron   •   Six Cities Share $745,000 In Grants Through The 2021 Childhood Obesity Prevention and Environmental Health and Sustainability Aw   •   Richard Patterson former Tesla designer of the Model S makes history as the first black manufacturer and designer of a Supercar   •   Seven Dow leaders achieve top honors on OUTstanding’s 2020 leading LGBT+ professionals lists   •   8 Women to Know in Sustainability in 2021   •   ddm marketing + communications Publishes Whitepaper On Integrating Media And Content Strategies   •   The Estée Lauder Companies to Webcast Discussion of Fiscal 2021 Second Quarter Results on February 5, 2021   •   Hope Hospice Uses Animatronic Pets in Dementia Care
Bookmark and Share

Victory Likely For Govt Against Arizona


 

ST. LOUIS — The lawsuit filed by the U.S. Justice Department against Arizona’s new immigration statute will likely prevail, at least in part, but its victory may come only at the appellate stage.

The first round of the legal battle will be a decision by an Arizona federal district judge about whether to prevent Arizona SB 1070 from becoming effective July 29. That judge’s decision is a “wild card,” according to Stephen Legomsky, JD, DPhil, immigration policy expert and professor of law at Washington University in St. Louis.

“It’s very hard to predict what the district court is going to do,” says Legomsky, the John S. Lehmann University Professor. “Its decision will be made by just one randomly selected judge, and that judge will be an Arizona resident who might come under intense personal pressure to defend his or her state’s law against federal intervention.’’

Regardless of the initial outcome, Legomsky predicts that the losing side is almost certain to appeal to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which covers most of the western United States. There, a panel of at least three judges drawn from a broader region will decide the case.

“They will be more likely than a district judge sitting in Arizona to invalidate at least portions of the law,” Legomsky believes. “Then, of course, there is always the possibility of a definitive ruling by the Supreme Court.”

LAW ENFORCEMENT INTERROGATION MOST LIKELY PORTION TO STAND

Much of the outcry over the statute deals with a mandate for police officers to investigate the statuses of anyone they lawfully stop whenever they have a “reasonable suspicion” that the person is unlawfully present. The law does not say what will make a suspicion reasonable, and many fear that racial profiling will therefore become more widespread.

Other controversial provisions, however, make certain immigration-related conduct a state criminal offense. Legomsky predicts that at least the latter provisions will be struck down as illegal interferences with the exclusive federal power to set the nation’s immigration policies.

For example, the Arizona law makes it a state crime for an undocumented immigrant to be present in the state.

“While Congress has indeed made illegal entry a federal criminal offense. It has consciously chosen not to criminalize overstaying a visa; for visa overstayers, Congress has decided that deportation is a sufficient sanction,’’ Legomsky observes. "Thus, Arizona’s law is directly at odds with the federal immigration laws. Further, even for individuals who entered illegally, Congress had to balance a range of factors before settling on the proper level of punishment.”

“By increasing the penalty, Arizona has substituted its judgment for that of Congress. And for the past 100 years, the Supreme Court has consistently held that the regulation of immigration is exclusively a federal responsibility. Whether you feel that the existing penalties are too harsh, too weak, or just right, we can’t have 50 states and hundreds of cities and towns each passing their own immigration laws.”

Even so, Legomsky says it is likely other states will “go ahead and pass copycat immigration legislation before this case is ultimately resolved.”

NO LAW IS FOOLPROOF

Supporters of the Arizona law assert the statute is necessary because the federal government fails to adequately secure U.S. borders. But Legomsky points out that the Obama administration has committed massive new resources to border fences, border patrol personnel, and new technologies.

“No law is capable of 100 percent enforcement,” Legomsky says. “It’s easy to criticize the federal government for failing to stem illegal immigration, but the real question is how much in the way of taxpayer resources do supporters want the federal government to spend on immigration enforcement?”

 



Back to top
| Back to home page
Video

White House Live Stream
LIVE VIDEO EVERY SATURDAY
alsharpton Rev. Al Sharpton
9 to 11 am EST
jjackson Rev. Jesse Jackson
10 to noon CST


Video

LIVE BROADCASTS
Sounds Make the News ®
WAOK-Urban
Atlanta - WAOK-Urban
KPFA-Progressive
Berkley / San Francisco - KPFA-Progressive
WVON-Urban
Chicago - WVON-Urban
KJLH - Urban
Los Angeles - KJLH - Urban
WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
New York - WKDM-Mandarin Chinese
WADO-Spanish
New York - WADO-Spanish
WBAI - Progressive
New York - WBAI - Progressive
WOL-Urban
Washington - WOL-Urban

Listen to United Natiosns News